5. During the libel action that
James Whistler brought against John Ruskin in 1878 the following exchange took place between the artist and Sir John Holker, representing Ruskin: ‘How long did you take to knock off one of your pictures?’ Whistler: ‘Oh, I ‘
knock one off’ possibly in a couple of days. One day to do the work and another to finish it.’ Holker: ‘The labour of two days is that for which you ask two hundred guineas?’ ‘No, I ask it for a knowledge I have gained in the work of a lifetime.’ The case attracted considerable attention and a great deal was written about it. At the end of December 1878 Whistler published a pamphlet on it; a caricature appeared in
Punch (7 December 1878). See Ronald Anderson and Anne Koval,
James McNeill Whistler. Beyond the myth. London 1994, pp. 215-225, 490-491 (quotation on p. 219). In Van Gogh’s version Whistler’s reply is even more brazen: he speaks of two
hours instead of two
days.